What Is the Toulmin Model of Argument

The Toulmin model (or system) is a  six-part model of argument (with similarities to the syllogism) introduced by British philosopher Stephen Toulmin in his book The Uses of Argument (1958).   The Toulmin model (or system) can be used as a tool for developing, analyzing, and categorizing arguments. Observations What is it that makes arguments work? What makes arguments effective? The British logician Stephen Toulmin made important contributions to argument theory that are useful for this line of inquiry. Toulmin found six components of arguments:[T]he Toulmin model provides us with useful tools for analyzing the components of arguments.(J. Meany and K. Shuster, Art, Argument, and Advocacy. IDEA, 2002) Claim: A statement that something is so.Data: The backing for the claim.Warrant: The link between the claim and the grounds.Backing: Support for the warrant.Modality: The degree of certainty employed in offering the argument.Rebuttal: Exceptions to the initial claim.[Toulmins] general model of data leading to a claim, mediated by a warrant with any necessary backing, has been very influential as a new standard of logical thinking, particularly among scholars of rhetoric and speech communication.(C. W. Tindale, Rhetorical Argumentation. Sage, 2004) Using the Toulmin System Use the seven-part Toulmin system to begin to develop an argument . . .. Here is the Toulmin system: Make your claim.Restate or qualify your claim.Present good reasons to support your claim.Explain the underlying assumptions that connect your claim and your reasons. If an underlying assumption is controversial, provide backing for it.Provide additional grounds to support your claim.Acknowledge and respond to possible counterarguments.Draw a conclusion, stated as strongly as possible. (Lex Runciman, Carolyn Lengel, and Kate Silverstein,  Exercises to Accompany The Everyday Writer, 4th ed. Macmillan, 2009) The Toulmin Model and the Syllogism Toulmins model actually boils down to a rhetorical expansion of the syllogism . . .. Although the reactions of others are anticipated, the model is primarily directed at representing the argumentation for the standpoint of the speaker or writer who advances the argumentation. The other party remains in fact passive: The acceptability of the claim is not made dependent on a systematic weighing up of arguments for and against the claim.(F. H. van Eemeren and R. Grootendorst, A Systematic Theory of Argumentation. Cambridge University Press, 2004) Toulmin on the Toulmin Model When I wrote [The Uses of Argument], my aim was strictly philosophical: to criticize the assumption, made by most Anglo-American academic philosophers, that any significant argument can be put in formal terms . . ..In no way had I set out to expound a theory of rhetoric or argumentation: my concern was with twentieth-century epistemology, not informal logic. Still less had I in mind an analytical model like that which, among scholars of Communication, came to be called the Toulmin model.(Stephen Toulmin, The Uses of Argument, rev. ed. Cambridge Univ. Press, 2003)

Notes On The Global Financial Crisis Essay - 1431 Words

Abstract The recent turmoil in the global financial market has given rise to an argument on what policy measure or controls should be imposed to curb excess stock price volatility. One such restrictions were placed on short selling to reduce speculative trading.The aim of the present paper is to consider the impact of the measures placed on short selling following the 2008 global financial crisis. This report assesses the success of the interim measures in achieving these objectives, and also considers the impact the interim measures had on the market, participants in the market and other stakeholders What is short selling? The short sale of a security that is not owned by the seller of the stock, or the seller has borrowed. Short selling is the belief that the price of a security will decline, at a lower price to make a profit, you can buy it back at a reduced cost in future. There are two general types of short sale transactions: (A) short sales covered: a person sells a financial product they can trust agreement existing loan to have a right exercisable and unconditional to confer the product the buyer at the time of sale; and (B) short sales Uncovered: the seller has no arrangement in place to borrow the financial product at the time of sale and therefore does not have a right exercisable and unconditional to confer the product. 1 These measures included, in summary: (a) the temporary banning, with some exemptions, of the covered shortShow MoreRelatedNotes On The Global Financial Crisis1614 Words   |  7 Pageseither hedge risks or to open speculative positions. 1. Introduction The latest global financial crisis, starting from the United States since 2007, has pushed the financial derivatives to be a hot spot. The publics usually believe that the inappropriate application of derivatives should be to blame for this, which is totally wrong. It is apparent that there is no single financial crisis resulting from only a kind of financial product. Whatever the instrument is, including credit derivatives and basicRead MoreNotes on the Global Financial Crisis829 Words   |  3 Pages1. The global financial crisis did not reduce my income, but I think that if I did see reduced income, I would either cut back on discretionary purchases or I would buy cheaper brands. Certainly with things that I have to buy, like food or toiletries, cheaper brands are usually purchased. This contrasts with products that are completely discretionary, where my consumption might be severely curtailed or cut back entirely. The reason for this is simple. When there is less money to go aro und, and thereRead MoreAccounting Fraud721 Words   |  3 Pagesoutline in NOTE form. Submit this completed outline on Monday WK 4 together with your articles (4 or 5), a reference list notes on your articles that will be used as support for your arguments/points. Remember you MUST highlight the sections on the articles that you are going to use as support in your essay and you MUST write next to these sections, what paragraph in your essay the ideas will be used in. i.e. Definition paragraph, BP1, BP2, BP3. (BP = Body paragraph). Note: StudentsRead MoreBasel III1155 Words   |  5 PagesStudents will receive a Case Note on which to base their case analysis in response to the questions below. You will find it useful, if you do not have exposure to the case method, to review â€Å"How to Write a Case-Based Essay† [by William Ellet - provided]. Assignment questions 1. Discuss the relationship between the capital base of banks and the 2007-2010 global financial crisis. Using your own research, cite at least two examples of real world financial institutions. 2. Why is there a perceivedRead MoreThe Global Financial Crisis Of 2007-20081123 Words   |  5 PagesThe Global Financial Crisis of 2007-2008 is the worst financial crisis since the 1930’s The Great Depression (Reuters, 2009). Even if bailouts of banks by national governments prevented the collapse of major financial institutions, worldwide stock markets continued to drop. Evictions and foreclosures overwhelmed the housing market while severed unemployment embraced the labor market (Baily and Elliot, 2009). This global financial crisis was responsible for the decline in the consumers’ wealth, andRead MoreChina And China Case Study1578 Words   |  7 PagesThe fall in prime cost entails a rise in profits, so the profitability of corporations that have transferred their production to China goes beyond all reasonable limits. Moreover, the financial world crisis served as an impetus for this process to acquire a global meaning. At the same time, it is necessary to note the additional effect that the entire US economy receives from the transfer of production to China that is the stability of domestic prices. Inflation is held at a low level, despite theRead MoreIntroduction Of The Bank Of England986 Words   |  4 Pagesprivate banks in the Great Britain and Ireland gained freedom of issuing their own banknotes, while the notes issued by the provincial banking companies commonly under circulation. Over the years, a number of Acts of Parliament were subject to introduce by the UK Parliament in order to increase confidence in the banknotes that were in circulation through limiting on the rights of banks in issuing notes. This concept leads to general idea of this paper, which will look at the evolution of output, inflationRead MoreThe Impact Of Expansionary Monetary Policy During The Great Recession1720 Words   |  7 PagesInternational Monetary Fund (IMF) as the worst global recession of the 20th century s ince the Great Depression [1]. After eight years, global economies today continue to struggle to find sustainable recovery and robust growth. The crisis was a massive institutional failure that involved the bursting of the asset bubble, the collapse of the stock market, and the moribund employment rate among others. The crisis has since triggered economists, governments, and financial institutions to critically revisit theirRead MoreBanking Sectors and Financial Crisis in the UAE and GCC Countries890 Words   |  4 Pagesï » ¿Banking Sectors Financial Crisis in the UAE GCC Countries Chapter Two Table of Contents I. UAE GCC Countries Economy Overview Overview of the Banking Sector. Islamic and conventional Banking principles. The structure of Islamic Banking in UAE GCC Countries Islamic Banks operating in the UAE GCC Countries Central Bank Federal Law II. The financial crisis in the UAE GCC Countries. Causes of the financial crisis. Effects of the financial crisis. Banking Sector beforeRead MoreThe Financial Crisis And The G20 Essay1456 Words   |  6 PagesIntroduction: The collapse of the financial market in the United States created an accelerated momentum that pushed the global economy towards a detrimental downward spiral during 2008. In response to the crisis, the world’s top economies created the G20 leaders’ forum in order to manage the financial downturn. Although the crisis was somewhat managed by the G20, the Great Recession left the world with a weak and stagnate global economy. The rise of secular stagnation was a viable threat following

Cultural Component free essay sample

After all of the congratulations on seeing another year on this earth were done, we set out to our destination. Usually we just order pizza and call it a day but we wanted to make this day special. Our place of choice was the great Arawak Key, or as I like to call it, food central. As we arrived there was rake n’ scrape music playing and people dancing. It was also obvious that we weren’t the only ones with that idea. Hungry faces as far as the eye can see, but no one was as hungry as me. I searched all around for an empty restaurant to seat me family of five. It felt like it was hopeless because every restaurant we looked in, a full house of hungry faces looked back at us. We finally found a diamond in the rough with a slightly empty restaurant. This restaurant had a cozy feel to it. We will write a custom essay sample on Cultural Component or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page It had basic light brown paint and Bahamian art strung up on the walls. These paintings were probably purchase from schools which made me wish I did better in art. As we ordered our food another component of culture came to me. The menu was stacked with Bahamian dishes, from the almighty conch snack to the luxurious lobster and shrimp snacks. I ordered two different meals for myself only and when I was finished, I still wasn’t full. Secondly, I went to an event known as Fam Fest. This is a free gospel concert held annually on Arawak key. This brings up another cultural component which is beliefs. The majority of the Bahamas is of the Christian denomination. This was seen excellently with the numbers of people that showed up. Although it could have been due only to the fact that it was free, because something that is free and a Bahamian is never far apart. Getting back to topic, with a gathering of Bahamians there has to be food. The entire right sight of the venue was covered by vendors set upped to sell their dishes. Hundreds of people gathered to praise the lord and satisfy their stomachs, not a bad combination. Arawak key is a Bahamian culture haven. From the food, the music, and the dancing, it all is truly a culture filled place. Also the clothes worn by employees to accentuate their restaurant’s Bahamian qualities are brilliant. Firstly, the food is pure Bahamian influenced. The sound of conch salad being prepared fills the air and the smell of fried foods just flow through your nostrils. Furthermore, the rake n’ scrape music played by live bands or speakers just set the mood and make for the perfect Bahamian experience. Also, the dancing, although mostly done by drunken men and women, still gives a nice feel to the place. In conclusion, it is clear to say that the components of culture, or just culture itself is evident almost everywhere you go. Arawak Key is a perfect place to go if you want a true culture experience. Although some of the components are seen more than others, each of them plays a vital role in the complete culture of the Bahamas.

Relationship Between Language and Culture

Introduction Language and culture are intertwined. One cannot define or identify cultural orientations without citing variations in language. The purpose of the essay is to clearly highlight the issue of intercultural communication with reference to language.Advertising We will write a custom essay sample on Relationship Between Language and Culture specifically for you for only $16.05 $11/page Learn More What is culture? Culture describes variations in values, beliefs, as well as differences in the way people behave (DeVito 2007). Culture encompasses everything that a social group develops or produces. Element of culture are not genetically transmitted and as such, they have to be passed down from one generation the next through communication. This explains why it is easy to adopt a certain language depending on the shared beliefs, attitudes and values. The existence of different cultures can be explained using the cultural relativism approach which sti pulates that although cultures tend to vary, none is superior to the other (DeVito 2007). Learning of cultural values can be done through enculturation whereby individuals learn the culture of their birth. Alternatively, one can be acculturated into a culture that is divergent from their basic culture (DeVito 2007). Language and its role in culture Language is the verbal channel of communication by articulating words that an individual is conversant with. This is aimed at relaying information. In other words, it is the expression of one’s culture verbally (Jandt 2009). Language is the first element that helps an individual to distinguish the cultural orientations of individuals. Through language, we are able to differentiate between for example, a Chinese national and a Briton. The main functions of language are generally for information purposes and for the establishment of relationships.Advertising Looking for essay on cultural studies? Let's see if we can help you! Ge t your first paper with 15% OFF Learn More Different cultures perceive the use of language differently. Whereas an American regards it as a useful communication tool, a Chinese will use their language to relay their feelings and to establish relationships. It is through such variances of language that different cultures have placed on the usage of their language show the link between the two study variables (Jandt 2009). Role of language in cultural diversity Intercultural communication refers to communication between people from different cultural backgrounds. Due to the differences in cultures, there is a high probability that a message will be misunderstood and distorted. Difference in languages leads to challenges in the interpretation of for example, politeness, acts of speech and interaction management. Normally, differences in languages lead to impediments in understanding. This is due to the difference in perception in as far as values are concerned. Language shapes our lines of thought and as such, it is the core element that shapes how people perceive the world. The way people communicate is largely due to their cultures of origin. Language increases the rate of ethnocentrism in individuals thus furthering their self-centeredness in culture. As a result, they are less responsive to the different means of communication that are not similar to their own values and beliefs (McGregor eta al 2007). Language further heightens the aspect of accelerating cultural differences as it openly showcases the variations in communication. In turn, this view tends to impede negatively on intercultural efforts, thereby having a negative impact on the communication between individuals of different cultural orientations.Advertising We will write a custom essay sample on Relationship Between Language and Culture specifically for you for only $16.05 $11/page Learn More Conclusion There is need for individuals to evaluate the usage of language in order to effectively interpret the shared meanings that are meant to be communicated. It is important therefore that individuals from a multi cultural context look at each other beyond their differences in order to enable effective communication. Reference List DeVito, J A. (2006) Human communication the basic course, 10 th edition. Boston, Mass: Pearson / Allyn and Bacon. Jandt, F E. (2007) An introduction to intercultural communication: identities in global  community. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications, Inc. Mohan, T, McGregor, M T, Saunders, H Archee, S. (2008) Communicating as a  professional. Sydney, Australia: Cengage Learning. This essay on Relationship Between Language and Culture was written and submitted by user Nancy Lindsay to help you with your own studies. You are free to use it for research and reference purposes in order to write your own paper; however, you must cite it accordingly. You can donate your paper here.